We have been working with various merchandise management systems for twenty years and have compared many providers. We are extremely satisfied with JTL because the solutions meet our requirements and the system can grow with us step by step.
PlentyONE alternative
The right solution for your company
Are you looking for an alternative to PlentyONE? In this overview, you will find various ERP systems that are suitable for your company. We explain how these ERP solutions optimize your business processes and which functions are particularly important for your growth.
Companies that trust us

ERP systems in comparison
Stand: Juli 2025
Stand: Juli 2025









ERP, WMS, connectors, marketplaces, cash register, production, finance and accounting, customer service, price monitoring
ERP, WMS, connectors, marketplaces, cash register, production, finance and accounting, customer service, price monitoring
ERP, order management, marketplace and store connections, POS; financial accounting functions via exports and partner solutions
Wawi, CRM, production, project management
ERP & CRM, project management, accounting
Order processing, shipping, process automation
Accounting, ERP, CRM, project controlling
App-based: ERP, CRM, website, financial accounting, etc.
Composable Commerce, PIM, Order Management System
Finance, ERP, CRM, production, analysis
Middleware, marketplace integration, order routing
Very powerful and scalable, backed by a huge community and a free professional ERP system as a foundation.
Very powerful and scalable, backed by a huge community and a free professional ERP system as a foundation.
As an all-in-one system, it bidsder a wide range of functions that makes switching between tools superfluous.
Modern interface, enables a quick start and offers solid all-round functions for digital SMEs.
Integration of ERP and CRM, user-friendly, good for mapping width company processes.
Good, simple and inexpensive solution for the pure processing of multi-channel orders.
A comprehensive system for SMEs that is particularly impressive in the financial and CRM areas.
Customizable as open source software, benefits from a global ecosystem and offers full control.
The API-first approach enables flexibility and is well suited to complex digital strategies.
Is considered a global standard, is powerful in process mapping and offers investment security.
Specialized middleware for PIM and the management of complex multi-channel structures.
The training period may take longer, but the learning progress is rapid and pays off in the long term.
The training period may take longer, but the learning progress is rapid and pays off in the long term.
The high level of complexity can be overwhelming; the revenue-based pricing model penalizes growing success.
Costs can rise quickly as the number of users increases; eCommerce functions are less in-depth than with specialists.
The focus is not exclusively on eCommerce, which means that specialized functions for pure online retailers are missing.
Is not a fully-fledged ERP, as functions for ERP and purchasing are not included.
Less focused on eCommerce and can therefore be oversized for pure retailers.
Requires high set-up and maintenance costs as well as technical expertise or costly partners.
Focuses on enterprise customers, which means high costs and is not a quick solution for SMEs.
Very high costs and a long implementation period make it difficult for most SMEs to implement.
Is not a stand-alone ERP system and requires a leading software for ERP or financial accounting.
High:
Customizable via editions and extensions…
High:
Customizable via editions and extensions…
Low:
is designed as a complete solution and therefore follows less of a modular approach.
High:
Additional functions can be flexibly added as add-ons.
High:
There are various packages tailored to different company sizes.
Low:
Is focused on a clear process and not designed as a modular system.
High:
Has a modular structure to flexibly cover different areas of the company.
Extremely high:
Each function is a separate app that can be installed or omitted as required.
Extremely high:
Based on the idea of linking the best available individual solutions.
High:
A wide enterprise system with numerous industry-specific modules.
Low:
itself functions as a specialized module (middleware) for an existing ERP.
Fair:
The basic Wawi is free of charge, hosting costs grow with requirements, not with sales.
Fair:
The basic Wawi is free of charge, hosting costs grow with requirements, not with sales.
Revenue-based:
Costs increase directly in line with success, which makes budget planning more difficult.
Subscription model:
Costs per user and function package, can quickly become expensive with growth.
Subscription model:
Fixed monthly costs per user ensure good planning reliability.
Transaction-based:
A very inexpensive way to get started, where the costs grow with the order volume.
Subscription model:
Costs per user, which tend to be in the higher price segment.
Flexible:
The open source version is free of charge, additional costs are incurred for apps and hosting.
Individual:
High entry costs, as it is aimed at large companies with specific requirements.
Very high:
The total costs are made up of licenses, implementation and maintenance.
Individual:
The pricing is tailored to larger retailers with a high marketplace focus.
Very strong:
Specializes in sales via a large number of stores and eCommerce platforms.
Very strong:
Specializes in sales via a large number of stores and eCommerce platforms.
Very strong:
This is one of the core areas and one of the software’s greatest strengths.
Good:
Bidders good integration with the most important store systems and marketplaces.
Good:
Solid integrations are available, but it is not the core competence of the system.
Very strong:
The core competence of the software lies in the integration of as many sales channels as possible.
Good:
integrations are available, but are not the primary focus of the overall solution.
Good:
Requires setup and in some cases the use of third-party provider apps.
Very strong:
Designed for the implementation of complex omnichannel scenarios.
Good:
Specialized partner solutions and add-ons are generally used for implementation.
Extremely strong:
This is the absolute core competence and the main purpose of the software.
Very good:
A huge, active community, many partners, very detailed online documentation and optional support from the manufacturer.
Very good:
A huge, active community, many partners, very detailed online documentation and optional support from the manufacturer.
Good:
Bidders a large community and a partner network; direct support is fee-based.
Good:
Direct support via ticket system, supplemented by a help center and a learning platform (Academy).
Good:
Direct support from the manufacturer, the priority of which depends on the service package selected.
Good:
Bidders fast email support and very good online documentation.
Good:
Professional support is offered both by the manufacturer and by certified partners.
Community-supported:
A huge global community helps, professional support is provided by partners.
Partner-centric:
Implementation and support are handled entirely by agency partners.
Partner-dominated:
Both implementation and ongoing support are provided by certified SAP partners.
Good:
Bidders specialized manufacturer support tailored to the middleware.
PlentyONE alternative for many retailers

SWITCH TO JTL
How your migration works
Reach your goal with automation & service partners
Switching to JTL does not have to be time-consuming and expensive – with the targeted use of tools and the support of the right service partner, the project can be completed quickly and smoothly. Here is a guide including frequently asked questions(FAQ) from merchants who have already made the switch to JTL.

Frequently asked questions about the PlentyONE alternative
With JTL, you don’t automatically pay more just because your turnover increases. The central ERP is permanently free of charge. Costs only arise when you need extended functions or higher edition levels. This means your expenses remain predictable and your growth is not penalized.
Yes. With JTL-Workflows, you can automate your processes exactly as you wish. Instead of having to adapt to rigid processes, you create software that fully adapts to your company.
The changeover is very secure. You benefit from a huge community and hundreds of certified service partners who will support you with data migration and setup. This means that the switch is accompanied professionally and smoothly right from the start.
PlentyONE is particularly suitable for retailers who are looking for a highly integrated all-in-one system for classic multichannel retail and can live with a volume-based pricing model.
JTL, on the other hand, is aimed at companies that want to grow on a modular basis – from classic eCommerce retailers to logistics and fulfillment service providers to D2C brands and professional traders. JTL offers significantly more flexibility and long-term cost control thanks to its free ERP, strong warehouse and fulfillment components and a high level of integration capability.









